Make sure in your Search Settings that you:
Do not have too restrictive Search criteria
By example, only looking within narrow age range, too specific a height, limited Jewish outlook etc.
Expand your geographical range
By example, don't confine your search to a small town.city or even one state in United States.
We think it important to bear in mind, that over 70% of JWed's 3,700+ marriages have been between two people out-of-city, out-of-state and out-of-country. Yes many do meet and marry people more locally, but far more meet their soulmate, that needle-in-a-haystack with someone sometimes very far away geographically, but intimately close in attraction, shared life goals, desired character traits, shared Jewish outlook etc.
The #1 rule. Don't be rigid. Be flexible.
Your have rightly your non-negotiable. But but don't constrain yourself elsewhere.